| Year | Pony League | National League | American League |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | |||
| 2025 | Cardinals over Athletics | Athletics over Pirates | Royals over Giants |
| 2024 | Cardinals over Athletics | Yankees over Dodgers | Giants over Brewers |
| 2023 | Dodgers over Brewers | Cardinals over Astros | Giants over Brewers |
| 2022 | Cardinals over Dodgers | Cardinals over Dodgers | Orioles over Royals |
| 2021 | Brewers over Cardinals | Pirates over Cardinals | Royals over Giants |
| 2020 | Brewers over Dodgers | Pirates over Cardinals | Red Sox over Giants |
| 2019 | Cardinals over Yankees | Cardinals over Phillies | Cardinals over Red Sox |
| 2018 | Cardinals over White Sox | Astros over Cardinals | Mets over Pirates |
| 2017 | Brewers over Cardinals | Cardinals over Brewers | Angels over Royals |
| 2016 | Brewers over Yankees | Pirates over White Sox | Angels over Rangers |
| 2015 | Red Sox over Cardinals | Brewers over Cardinals | Red Sox over Yankees |
| 2014 | Red Sox over Phillies | Brewers over Pirates | Pirates over Brewers |
| 2013 | White Sox | White Sox over Cardinals | |
| 2012 | Giants over Cardinals | ||
| 2011 | Dodgers over White Sox | ||
| 2010 | Dodgers over Angels | ||
| 2009 | Dodgers over Yankees |
